CatGenie VS Petmate Giant Litter Pan

UPDATED Jun. 2020
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

Petmate Giant Litter Pan and CatGenie are highly popular litter boxes that outclass their competitors in many aspects. In this Petmate Giant Litter Pan vs. CatGenie comparison, we offer a thorough analysis of their most important features and discover which of them is slightly better than the other.

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
The Biggest Litter Pan On The Market
VS
CatGenie
Self-Washing, Self-Flushing, Litter-Free Cat Box

Highlights

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
The main advantages of Petmate Giant Litter Pan include:
  • Giant size;
  • Large litter capacity;
  • Excellent odor control;
  • Anti-microbial Microban layer;
  • No litter scatter or urine oversprays;
  • Comfort-grip tech;
  • Additional storage compartments;
  • Heavy-duty construction;
  • Stable bottom base;
  • Easy to use and clean.
  • Price: $21.33
CatGenie
CatGenie’s key features include:
  • Fully automated cleaning, waste disposal (flushing), and maintenance;
  • 3 cycle start options: manual, automatic, and cat-activated;
  • Cat motion sensor that informs the device when to start and pause the cleaning cycle;
  • Special Washable Granules used instead of litter, which are dust-free, eco-friendly, and pet-safe;
  • Unique sanitizing liquid that kills odors and germs;
  • Automated GenieHand that scoops the solids;
  • Hopper chamber with an impeller, where solids are liquefied;
  • Control panel child lock, which prevents children and cats from accidentally pushing buttons.
  • Price: $239.97

Compare Features

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
Type
Open Litter Box
Design
Petmate Giant Litter Pan features a simple one-piece design that hides a lot of useful and convenient features. The biggest portion of the box is reserved for the actual litter area with two convenient storage compartments on the side. The comfort-grip rails enable users to lift the box and carry it around without any problems. The base is specifically designed for stability. The box currently only comes in beige.
Dimensions
Petmate Giant Litter Pan measures:
  • 34.7" in length;
  • 19.8" in width;
  • 10" in height.
Installation Process
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not require any setup whatsoever. Just pour your favorite litter into the designated area and the box is ready for use.
Scooping Proces
Petmate Giant Litter Pan requires manual scooping. The frequency of scooping largely depends on your choice of litter and the number of cats in your household.
Noise Level
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not produce any noise.
Durability
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is made of heavy-duty pet-friendly plastic with a Microban layer for anti-microbial protection. It is a solid piece of sturdy plastic resistant to any types of structural damage, so it can last 5+ years.
Odor Control
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is coated with a layer of Microban, which destroys odor-inducing microorganisms.
Recommended For
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is primarily designed for larger cats. It can also be used by multiple smaller felines, but it is not recommended for kittens under 6 months of age and older or disabled cats.
Suitable For Multiple Cats
Litter Compatibility
Petmate Giant Litter Pan can work with any type/brand of litter.
Recommended Liners
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not use liners.
Cleaning & Maintenance
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is extremely easy to clean. Depending on the number of cats in your household, you can thoroughly clean the box once a month with a soft cloth and some mild detergent. It can be fully immersed in water.
Training Considerations
Your cat should not have a problem with using Petmate Giant Litter Pan from day one.
Safety Considerations
/
Cost
$21.33
Money-Back Guarantee
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not come with a money-back guarantee
Warranty
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is covered by Amazon's general 30-day warranty.
CatGenie
Type
Self-Washing, Self-Flushing Cat Box (Open-Top, Hood Bought Separately)
Design
CatGenie is a gray-and-white litter box in the shape of a toilet bowl, consisting of a base, brim, bowl, and a canister-like construction that contains the electronic elements. It features an automated hand that scoops the solids and the bowl has drain holes that allow the liquids to fall into a reservoir with odor-killing sanitizing liquid. It is an open-top litter box, but a custom-designed hood can be bought separately if your cat likes privacy.
Dimensions
CatGenie measures:
  • 24.5 inches in length;
  • 19.25 inches in width;
  • 21 inches in height;
  • 230 square inches in usable cat space (basin).
Installation Process
CatGenie needs to be hooked up to a cold water line and waste-water drain and plugged into an electrical outlet. The process should not take longer than 15 minutes and it is explained in details in the CatGenie setup manual. All necessary supplies are provided in the package, excluding a pair of pliers. Although the manufacturer claims that a plumber's assistance is not needed to complete the installation process, inexperienced users may need the help of a professional.
Scooping Proces
CatGenie fully eliminates the need for scooping.
Noise Level
CatGenie's cleaning cycle lasts less than half an hour. For 26 minutes, the noise it emits is rather quiet and cannot be heard through closed doors. During the cycle, there are 3 brief periods when the sound of water draining can be heard. It is no louder than a washing machine, but it can bother cats that are particularly sensitive to noise.
Durability
CatGenie is mostly made of durable plastic, with the exception of pins that are made of aluminum and the motor that is made of heavy-duty materials. Its solid construction and high-quality materials guarantee that it can last for years to come.
Odor Control
Since CatGenie flushes the waste and thoroughly cleans the granules and the bowl with water and sanitizing liquid during the cleaning process, odors are only present from the point when the cat does his or her business until the point when the cleaning cycle takes place. Unfortunately, the granules are not absorbent and do not minimize odor. It is recommended to program CatGenie to start the cleaning cycle 10 or 30 minutes after the cat uses it to keep the bowl odor-free.
Recommended For
CatGenie is best suited for cats aged 6 months or older and weighing up to 20 pounds. Cats aged 8 weeks to 6 months should use CatGenie with supervision.
Suitable For Multiple Cats
Litter Compatibility
CatGenie does not use litter. It exclusively uses proprietary Washable Granules.
Recommended Liners
CatGenie does not require the use of liners.
Cleaning & Maintenance
With CatGenie, the cleaning process is fully automated and the same goes for maintenance. You only need to purchase SaniSolution cartridges containing sanitizing liquid used for cleaning and maintenance cartridges that are used every 2-4 months to thoroughly clean hard-to-reach spots. With both types of cartridges, you only need to pop them in and CatGenie does the rest.
Training Considerations
CatGenie is an unusual litter box and the acclimation period can last anywhere from several days to several weeks, depending on your cat’s personality. To help your cat get used to CatGenie, you can place treats and toys in and around CatGenie, praise your cat when he or she explores the new litter box, and wait until you introduce your friend to the strange sound of the cleaning cycle. At first, you should keep the old box next to CatGenie, but you should stop cleaning it, so your cat can naturally move on to the new, clean box.
Safety Considerations
CatGenie is completely safe to use. There are no shock hazards or sharp elements to worry about, all surface that your cat comes in contact with are smooth and non-toxic, the sanitizing liquid and granules are pet-safe, and the device pauses the cleaning cycle if your cat jumps into the bowl mid-cycle.
Cost
$239.97
Money-Back Guarantee
CatGenie comes with a 90-day money-back guarantee.
Warranty
CatGenie comes with a 2-year manufacturer's warranty.

Compare Ratings

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
FINAL RATING
8.1/10
Design & Size
Materials & Durability
Odor Control
Cleaning & Maintenance
Ease Of Use & Comfort
Value For Money
CatGenie
FINAL RATING
8.5/10
Design & Size
Materials & Durability
Odor Control
Cleaning & Maintenance
Ease Of Use & Comfort
Value For Money

Compare User Reviews

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
  • Submitted By Mia Black on 09/20/2018
    This thing is a beast! My babies absolutely love it and there were no problems with transition whatsoever. The storage thingies on the bottom (I guess) aren’t really necessary imo, but ok you can put a scoop in there and other things your cats wouldn’t be tempted to play with. It’s also pretty big for our small place but it is what it is.
  • Submitted By Jenna Baylis on 07/20/2018
    I couldn’t believe how big this thing really is. I mean, I read the measurements online, but seeing it in person is a whole different experience. My fat spoiled brat fits without any problems with a lot of room to spare. I like how I can just dump a bunch of litter inside and just scoop the clumps every day instead of having to replace everything every couple of days.
CatGenie
  • Submitted By Lisa Frankel on 05/28/2018
    Does what it is supposed to do but the cleaning cycles take forever and my kitty hates noise, so I have to start the cycles manually and keep the doors closed so she doesn't get annoyed or scared. It really isn't noisier than a washing machine, but it is still noisier than I would like it to be.
  • Submitted By John Robertson on 05/02/2018
    Surprisingly, my 2 cats (both 8 months old) took to it right away. I didn't even have to use any particular tricks, I just threw their 2 favorite toys inside the bowl and left a few treats on the brim. We've been using it for 2 months, no problems so far, hope it stays that way.
  • Submitted By Daniel Grant on 04/21/2018
    I am pretty disappointed. When I saw this litter box, I was like, wow, this seems awesome! But then I bought it and the setup was so annoyingly complicated, it took a month for my cats to get used to it, and it smelled pretty bad at first because I tried not to turn it on that often so my cats don't get scared. It works ok, but I expected so much more.

Winner

CatGenie self-cleaning, self-flushing cat box is advertised as a hands-free solution that requires no manual work on the part of the cat guardian. Everything is automated, from cleaning and waste removal to maintenance. Find out if this unusual, no-scooping litter box is as good as it seems in our objective and detailed CatGenie review.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.