Modkat Litter Box VS Petmate Giant Litter Pan

UPDATED Oct. 2020
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

This in-depth Petmate Giant Litter Pan vs. Modkat Litter Box comparison was designed to help you easily decide between your top 2 choices. View Petmate Giant Litter Pan and Petmate Giant Litter Pan ’s most prominent features below and find out which of these excellent litter boxes has more to offer to cats and their humans.

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
The Biggest Litter Pan On The Market
VS
Modkat Litter Box
The Most Stylish Top-Entry Litter Box

Highlights

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
The main advantages of Petmate Giant Litter Pan include:
  • Giant size;
  • Large litter capacity;
  • Excellent odor control;
  • Anti-microbial Microban layer;
  • No litter scatter or urine oversprays;
  • Comfort-grip tech;
  • Additional storage compartments;
  • Heavy-duty construction;
  • Stable bottom base;
  • Easy to use and clean.
  • Price: $21.33
Modkat Litter Box
Modkat's highlights include:
  • All-in-one litter box;
  • Very easy to use and clean;
  • Top-entry construction;
  • Prevents litter tracking;
  • Reusable tarp liner;
  • Seamless base of the box;
  • Excellent for side pee-ers;
  • Dog-proof.
  • Price: $89.99

Compare Features

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
Type
Open Litter Box
Design
Petmate Giant Litter Pan features a simple one-piece design that hides a lot of useful and convenient features. The biggest portion of the box is reserved for the actual litter area with two convenient storage compartments on the side. The comfort-grip rails enable users to lift the box and carry it around without any problems. The base is specifically designed for stability. The box currently only comes in beige.
Dimensions
Petmate Giant Litter Pan measures:
  • 34.7" in length;
  • 19.8" in width;
  • 10" in height.
Installation Process
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not require any setup whatsoever. Just pour your favorite litter into the designated area and the box is ready for use.
Scooping Proces
Petmate Giant Litter Pan requires manual scooping. The frequency of scooping largely depends on your choice of litter and the number of cats in your household.
Noise Level
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not produce any noise.
Durability
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is made of heavy-duty pet-friendly plastic with a Microban layer for anti-microbial protection. It is a solid piece of sturdy plastic resistant to any types of structural damage, so it can last 5+ years.
Odor Control
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is coated with a layer of Microban, which destroys odor-inducing microorganisms.
Recommended For
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is primarily designed for larger cats. It can also be used by multiple smaller felines, but it is not recommended for kittens under 6 months of age and older or disabled cats.
Suitable For Multiple Cats
Litter Compatibility
Petmate Giant Litter Pan can work with any type/brand of litter.
Recommended Liners
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not use liners.
Cleaning & Maintenance
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is extremely easy to clean. Depending on the number of cats in your household, you can thoroughly clean the box once a month with a soft cloth and some mild detergent. It can be fully immersed in water.
Training Considerations
Your cat should not have a problem with using Petmate Giant Litter Pan from day one.
Safety Considerations
/
Cost
$21.33
Money-Back Guarantee
Petmate Giant Litter Pan does not come with a money-back guarantee
Warranty
Petmate Giant Litter Pan is covered by Amazon's general 30-day warranty.
Modkat Litter Box
Type
Top-Entry Litter Box
Design
Modkat sports a very simple yet stylish and chic design that goes well with any type of furniture. It includes a seamless base paired with a swivel lid that locks in place, meaning there are no moving parts that could get loose or broken. The surface of the box is 100% smooth without any sharp corners or crevices. The box comes in white, gray, and black.
Dimensions
Modkat is ideal for smaller and medium cats. It measures:
  • 16" in length;
  • 16" in width;
  • 15" in height.

The height of the liner is 10".

Installation Process
Assembling Modkat includes 4 simple steps:
  • Push the four liner hooks into their designated corner slots;
  • Position the liner inside the base with the open side facing front;
  • Hang the liner grommets from their hooks;
  • Install the walk-off platform.
Scooping Proces
ModProducts LLC. recommends using an all-natural or organic clumping litter with the litter box. As for scooping, simply swivel the lid out of the way and gather the clumps with the provided scoop. If two cats are using the box, you should scoop at least once every day.
Noise Level
Modkat litter box emits zero noise.
Durability
Modkat is made of durable and pet-friendly materials. The liner is a commercial-grade tarp, which has application in countless fields due to its durability. The overall design of the box is pretty simple, so there is nothing that could be easily broken.
Odor Control
When it comes to urine, Modkat provides exquisite odor control thanks to its super absorbent liner. As far as poop is concerned, odor levels depend on your choice of litter.
Recommended For
Modkat is designed for smaller and medium cats (up to 12lbs). It is not suited for dogs or older cats that might have problems with jumping or climbing.
Suitable For Multiple Cats
Litter Compatibility
Modkat recommends using an all-natural or organic clumping litter.
Recommended Liners
Modkat comes with a proprietary reusable liner that should last for about 3 months. After that time, you can order replacements directly from the company.
Cleaning & Maintenance
Modkat does not require a lot of maintenance. Scooping frequency depends on your chosen litter and the number of cats using the box. The liner should be replaced every three months and you can also wash it with water and mild dish soap. You should completely replace the litter every month. DO NOT wash the liner in your dishwasher or washing machine.
Training Considerations
With Modkat, no special training is required. However, you can start off by placing it next to your cat's old litter box and allowing him or her to start using it gradually.
Safety Considerations
Modkat Litter Box is perfectly safe for your cat since it does not include any electrical components or sharp or protruding elements.
Cost
$89.99
Money-Back Guarantee
Modkat comes with a full 30-day money-back guarantee.
Warranty
ModProducts LLC. offers a 1-year warranty for all defects in materials and craftsmanship.

Compare Ratings

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
FINAL RATING
8.1/10
Design & Size
Materials & Durability
Odor Control
Cleaning & Maintenance
Ease Of Use & Comfort
Value For Money
Modkat Litter Box
FINAL RATING
9.6/10
Design & Size
Materials & Durability
Odor Control
Cleaning & Maintenance
Ease Of Use & Comfort
Value For Money

Compare User Reviews

Petmate Giant Litter Pan
  • Submitted By Mia Black on 09/20/2018
    This thing is a beast! My babies absolutely love it and there were no problems with transition whatsoever. The storage thingies on the bottom (I guess) aren’t really necessary imo, but ok you can put a scoop in there and other things your cats wouldn’t be tempted to play with. It’s also pretty big for our small place but it is what it is.
  • Submitted By Jenna Baylis on 07/20/2018
    I couldn’t believe how big this thing really is. I mean, I read the measurements online, but seeing it in person is a whole different experience. My fat spoiled brat fits without any problems with a lot of room to spare. I like how I can just dump a bunch of litter inside and just scoop the clumps every day instead of having to replace everything every couple of days.
Modkat Litter Box
  • Submitted By Peter Howard on 02/10/2019
    We’ve had it for around two months now and it definitely gets the job done. It’s also pretty easy to clean once you remove the top lid and you can even hang the scoop that came with it by the side. If you have large dogs in your home they will definitely try to get in and flip it in the process which will spill some of the litter on the floor. I definitely recommend putting it where dogs can’t get to it.
  • Submitted By Anna Adams on 09/28/2018
    Great litter box for shy cats who like their privacy while doing their business. An extra benefit is that our dog can’t really get in and start eating the poop (gross, I know). The box is pretty roomy but I don’t see it accommodating two or more cats, especially if they’re overly territorial.
  • Submitted By George Irons on 06/28/2018
    Not bad, but too damn expensive for a glorified s**tbucket!
  • Submitted By Mila Jensen on 03/24/2018
    Great little box! I though my babies won’t be able to use it properly since they weren’t accustomed to top loaders, but it took them only a couple of days of sniffing and investigating and they love it now! I also have a cat that’s missing one leg, and would really wish she could use it too, but she can’t.

Winner

Modkat is a well-known top-entry litter box designed and manufactured by ModProducts LLC. It sports a modern and chic design, sturdy, utilitarian construction with very few moving parts, and excellent measures against litter tracking, unpleasant odors, and urine leaks. Read all about it in our comprehensive Modkat Litter Box review.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.